The short answer
For learning the spelling itself, studies with young children find little difference between typing a word and writing it, as long as the child spells it from memory instead of copying it or picking letters from a set. Two things tip the balance toward paper: a child who types slowly learns less from typing, and the Friday test is handwritten. Use both: games and typed practice for repetition, and the list on paper before the test.
Spelling homework used to mean writing each word five times. Now a lot of it happens on a tablet, and a fair question follows: does a child learn a word as well by typing it as by writing it?
The tool matters less than most parents expect. What matters more is whether your child is pulling the spelling out of memory or just recognizing it, and whether they get some practice in the format the test uses.
What the studies found
The research is smaller and more mixed than the headlines suggest.
- Spelling words: little difference. In a 2014 study, second graders learned new words either by printing them or by typing them. Both groups learned them well, and about equally. Studies in the 1990s went back and forth on the same question.
- Keyboard skill decides how well typing works. In that same study, children with weaker keyboard skills learned less when they practiced by typing. A child who hunts for each key is spending attention on the keyboard instead of the word.
- Letter shapes: handwriting helps. When adults learned an unfamiliar alphabet, the ones who wrote the letters by hand learned them faster and used them better than the ones who typed. That study was with adults, but it’s a reason to keep a pencil in the mix for young children still learning to form letters.
What matters more than the tool
Spelling a word from memory is harder than recognizing it, and the harder version is the one that sticks. Both kinds turn up on paper and on screens:
- Recognition: copying from the sheet, finding the word in a word search, choosing the next letter from a few on offer.
- Recall: hearing the word and spelling it with nothing to look at, whether typed or written.
Recognition practice is still useful, especially early in the week while the words are new and a child needs easy wins. By the night before the test, most of the practice should be recall.
Why paper still matters
Even if typing and writing teach the spelling equally well, the test is almost always on paper. Writing adds its own problems: forming each letter, mixing up b and d, keeping up while the teacher moves on. A child who has only ever typed the list can know every word and still trip over those.
The giveaway is a word that’s right on the keyboard and wrong on paper, and the fix is a few more goes by hand.
A week that uses both
- Early in the week: games and typed practice. Your child gets lots of goes with quick feedback, and they’ll want to do it.
- Midweek: a typed test with no hints, so you can see which words are still being missed.
- The night before: the whole list on paper, read aloud, the way the teacher will give it.
- After that: for any word missed on paper, look at it, say it, cover it, write it from memory, then check. Once or twice is enough. Writing it five times while looking at it is mostly copying.
For a younger child, or one still slow on a keyboard, put a little more of the week on paper. An older child who types well can do more of it on a screen.
Doing both in Spelling Stream
In Spelling Stream, the games where letters are on screen to choose from are the recognition end. With Pro, Letter Distractors makes some of the wrong letters ones children really write, so a right answer takes more than ruling letters out. The typed Practice Test and Final Test are recall on a keyboard built for children, with no autocorrect and no word suggestions to give the answer away.
For the paper part, the Written Test reads each word aloud while your child writes it, then shows the whole list so they can check the paper.